126 V. LEGAL ASSESSMENT › 1. Existence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › Existence of aid in the case of State guarantees, Decision_act (EU) 2020/394

In forcesince 7 Oct 2019

Consequently, the State guarantees gave a benefit to the borrowers since they did not have to pay any premium for them. Therefore, the requirement of economic advantage for ascertaining the existence of aid in the case at hand has been fulfilled. Repeating the relevant excerpts from Section 2.2 of the Commission Notice on Guarantees [See also ‘Commission Notice of 2000’, Section 2.1.1.], the opening decision stated that compared to a situation without guarantee, the State guarantee enables the borrowers to obtain better financial terms for loans than those normally available on the financial markets (see recital 39 of the present Decision). The Greek authorities challenged this statement (see recital 95) by arguing that the State guarantees do not influence the conditions for the granting of a loan and that there is no comparison with a situation without guarantee because financial institutions always ask for a guarantee in order to grant a loan. These arguments cannot be accepted. In offering more certainty to the financial institution that the loan contract with the borrower will be honoured, guarantees by definition improve the financial terms of loans. This is all the more so if financial institutions refuse to grant a loan without a guarantee, as the Greek authorities suggest. In such cases, it is only thanks to the guarantee that the borrower has access to and can benefit from a loan.