Section 3.4 of the Commission Notice on Guarantees provides a list of conditions, the cumulative fulfilment of which would rule out the presence of State aid. It seemed that the measure in question did not fulfil all of these conditions. In particular, the schemes appeared not to be closed to borrowers in financial difficulty, as required by point (a) of Section 3.4 of the Commission Notice on Guarantees. The Greek authorities submitted that firms in difficulty were excluded from the schemes, since undertakings had to submit viability studies prior to receiving the State guarantee. However, on the basis of the wording of Decision No 2/54310/0025/13.9.2007 (OJHR Β’ 1858/13.9.2007) the obligation to submit a viability study only applied to undertakings, which applied for a debt rearrangement for an amount over EUR 100000,00, as quoted in recital 23. Therefore, it seemed that there was no exclusion of firms in difficulty for other beneficiaries under scheme A nor for all beneficiaries under scheme B. In addition, on the basis of its reasoning in recitals 88 and 89 of Commission Decision 2012/307/EU [Commission Decision 2012/307/EU of 19 October 2011 regarding State aid schemes implemented by Greece in the Kastoria, Evia, Florina, Kilkis, Rodopi, Evros, Xanthi and Dodecanese Prefectures, and the islands of Lesbos, Samos and Chios (debt restructuring) (Nos C 23/04 (ex NN 153/03), C 20/05 (ex NN 70/04) and C 50/05 (ex NN 20/05) (OJ L 153, 14.6.2012, p. 16).], the Commission could not accept this argument in the light of the aforementioned Ministerial Decision. That Decision stated that the viability study will include ‘The company’s total liabilities after settlement of its debt to the credit system, its suppliers, insurance funds, the government and general market as well agreements on arrangements for the repayment of those liabilities’. Thus, it could not be excluded that aid was granted to firms in difficulty, since the viability study itself factored in the debt restructuring on the basis of scheme A. In other words, the viability study focused on the viability prospects of the beneficiaries post-restructuring of their debt on the basis of scheme A. This implies that applicants could have been in difficulty at the time of the study, but may nevertheless have been admitted to scheme A because a potential return to viability was predicted after receiving the aid.
41 III. Doubts raised by the Commission in the opening decision › 1. Existence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › State guarantee, Decision_act (EU) 2020/394
In forcesince 7 Oct 2019