40 III. Doubts raised by the Commission in the opening decision › 1. Existence of aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › State guarantee, Decision_act (EU) 2020/394

In forcesince 7 Oct 2019

The fact that beneficiaries in scheme A had to provide collaterals if their renegotiated debt exceeded EUR 100000,00 (see above recital 23), did not change the assessment that there was an aid element in the State guarantee granted even in these cases. The relevant observations made by the Commission in its Decision 2012/320/EU [Commission Decision 2012/320/EU of 25 January 2012 concerning the aid granted by Greece to cerealproducing farmers and cereal-collecting cooperatives (SA 27354 (C 36/10) (ex NN 3/10, ex CP 11/09) (OJ L 164, 23.6.2012, p. 10).], which were upheld by the General Court in its judgment in Case T-150/12 [Judgment of the General Court of 9 April 2014, Greece v Commission, Case T-150/12, EU:T:2014:191, paragraphs 82–85.], applied also to the present case. Thus, even when the beneficiaries had provided for collaterals, the State guarantee constituted aid since it depended on the discretion of the State whether to make use of the rights granted by the collateral agreements, should the beneficiaries have failed to pay back the loans. This was the case, as there seemed to be no provision in the legal basis of the schemes that provided for the automatic activation of the collateral agreements if the beneficiaries failed to pay the loans. Lastly, it was unclear whether the collateral had to secure in all cases the full amount of the loan. It was also unclear whether the collateral played any role in the calculation of the applicable premium (if any).

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (septième chambre) du 9 avril 2014. République hellénique contre Commission européenne.Decision

    9 Apr 2014 · 62012TJ0150

  • Decision_act (EU) 2012/320Law