4. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 4.1. Existence of aid › 4.1.3. Selectivity › 4.1.3.2. Derogation from the system of reference, Decision_act (EU) 2018/160

In forcesince 30 Jun 2017
(53)

Poland makes a distinction between ‘bracketed progressivity’ and ‘global progressivity’ and claims that, since all tax rates (i.e. the tax exemption equivalent to a 0 % rate, and the 1,4 % and 0,8 % rates) are applied on the same terms to all undertakings, there is no derogation from the reference system. However, both types of progressive taxation lead to different average effective rates being applied to different companies based on their turnover – which is the object of taxation – and ultimately their size. As the following example of three retailers (taxable persons) generating monthly turnovers of respectively PLN 10 million, PLN 100 million and PLN 750 million illustrates, although all retailers are subjected to the same tax rates and although the same portion of their income falls within the same three brackets, their effective average tax rates differ considerably. Indeed for each PLN 100 of turnover generated, Retailer 1 bears no tax, Retailer 2 bears an amount of tax of around PLN 0,7 and Retailer 3 an amount of tax of around PLN 1,2.

Monthly revenue from retail sales |

Retailer 1

PLN 10 million

Retailer 2

PLN 100 million

Retailer 3

PLN 750 million

Tax due on portion of revenue not exceeding PLN 17 million | 0 | 0 | 0

Tax due on portion of revenue above PLN 17 million but not exceeding PLN 170 million | — |

PLN 664000

(PLN 82999999 × 0,008)

PLN 1224000

(PLN 152999999 × 0,008)

Tax due on portion of revenue above PLN 170 million | — | — |

PLN 8120000

(PLN 579999999 × 0,014)

Total tax due | 0 | PLN 664000 | PLN 9344000

Effective average tax rate | 0 % | 0,664 % | 1,246 %