46 4. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 4.1. Existence of aid › 4.1.3. Selectivity › 4.1.3.1. System of reference, Decision_act (EU) 2018/160

In forcesince 30 Jun 2017

The Commission also does not consider that the progressive tax rate structure laid down by the Act forms a part of the reference system. The Court of Justice has specified that it is not always sufficient to confine the selectivity analysis to whether the measure derogates from the reference system as defined by the Member State [Joined Cases C-106/09 P and C-107/09 P Commission and Spain v Government of Gibraltar and United Kingdom EU:C:2011:732.]. It is also necessary to evaluate whether the boundaries of that system have been designed by the Member State in a consistent manner or, conversely, in a clearly arbitrary or biased way, so as to favour certain undertakings over others. Otherwise, instead of laying down general rules applying to all undertakings from which a derogation is made for certain undertakings, the Member State could achieve the same result, side stepping the State aid rules, by adjusting and combining its rules in such a way that their very application results in a different burden for different undertakings [Ibid, paragraph 92.]. It is particularly important to recall in that respect that the Court of Justice has consistently held that Article 107(1) of the Treaty does not distinguish between measures of State intervention by reference to their causes or their aims, but defines them in relation to their effects, and thus independently of the techniques used [Case C-487/06 P British Aggregates v Commission EU:C:2008:757, paragraphs 85 and 89 and the case-law cited, and Case C-279/08 P Commission v Netherlands (NOx) EU:C:2011:551, paragraph 51].

  • Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 15 November 2011. European Commission (C-106/09 P) and Kingdom of Spain (C-107/09 P) v Government oDecision

    15 Nov 2011 · 62009CJ0106

  • Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 22 December 2008. British Aggregates Association v Commission of the European Communities and UniteDecision

    22 Dec 2008 · 62006CJ0487

  • Judgment of the Court (Third Chamber) of 8 September 2011. European Commission v Kingdom of the Netherlands.Decision

    8 Sep 2011 · 62008CJ0279

  • Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union107Law