36 4. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 4.1. Existence of aid › 4.1.1. State resources and imputability to the State, Decision_act (EU) 2018/160

In forcesince 30 Jun 2017

As regards the measure's financing through State resources, the Court of Justice has consistently held that a measure by which the public authorities grant certain undertakings a tax exemption which, although not involving a positive transfer of State resources, places the persons to whom it applies in a more favourable financial situation than other taxpayers constitutes State aid [See Joined Cases C-106/09 P and C-107/09 P Commission v. Government of Gibraltar and United Kingdom EU:C:2011:732, paragraph 72 and the case-law cited therein.]. In recitals 37 to 60, the Commission will demonstrate that the progressive rate structure of the retail tax, described in recitals 15 and 16, results in Poland waiving tax revenue it would otherwise have been entitled to collect from retail operators with a lower level of turnover (and thus smaller retailers), if they had been subject to the same average effective retail tax rate as retail operators with a higher level of turnover (and thus larger retailers). The progressive rate structure's discrimination between retailers based on their size notably results in Poland waiving tax revenue it would otherwise have been entitled to collect from retail undertakings that operate under a franchise model as compared to retail undertaking that operate under a holding company model [Retail undertakings that own and operate several shops of a retail chain and are, for the purpose of the retail tax, regarded as one single taxable person.]. By renouncing those revenues, the retail tax gives rise to a loss of State resources within the meaning of Article 107(1) of the Treaty [See Case C-169/08 Presidente del Consiglio dei Ministri EU:C:2009:709, paragraph 58.].

  • Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 15 November 2011. European Commission (C-106/09 P) and Kingdom of Spain (C-107/09 P) v Government oDecision

    15 Nov 2011 · 62009CJ0106

  • Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 17 November 2009. Presidente del Consiglio dei Ministri v Regione Sardegna.Decision

    17 Nov 2009 · 62008CJ0169

  • Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union107Law