47 4. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 4.1. Existence of aid › 4.1.3. Selectivity › 4.1.3.1. System of reference, Decision_act (EU) 2018/160

In forcesince 30 Jun 2017

The result of the progressive rate structure laid down by the Act is that undertakings with low turnover from retail sales are either not subject to the retail tax or subject to the tax at substantially lower average effective rates – i.e. for each zloty of monthly turnover generated – than undertakings with high turnover, thereby reducing the charges that undertakings with low turnover have to bear as compared to undertakings with high turnover. Because each company is taxed at a different average effective tax rate, it is not possible for the Commission to identify one single reference rate. Poland has also not presented any specific rate as the reference rate or ‘normal’ rate and also did not explain why a higher rate would be justified by exceptional circumstances for retail operators with a high level of turnover, or why lower rates should apply to operators with lower levels of turnovers. The effect of the progressive rate structure of the tax is therefore that different undertakings pay different effective taxation rates depending on their monthly turnover and, consequently, on their size and the operating model. Consequently, the progressive tax rate structure introduced by the Act can be said to be specifically designed to favour smaller retailers over larger ones by applying different tax rates to the monthly turnover generated by undertakings involved in the sale of goods to natural person consumers and thereby subjecting undertakings with lower turnover to a lower average effective tax rate than undertakings with a higher turnover, which also tend to be foreign-owned [Joined Cases C-106/09 P and C-107/09 P Commission and Spain v Government of Gibraltar and United Kingdom EU:C:2011:732.], although both types of undertaking are engaged in the same activity.

  • Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 15 November 2011. European Commission (C-106/09 P) and Kingdom of Spain (C-107/09 P) v Government oDecision

    15 Nov 2011 · 62009CJ0106