77 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURES › 5.1. Presence of State aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) TFEU › 5.1.4. Selectivity › Justification based on the nature and general scheme of the system, Decision_act (EU) 2017/2116

In forcesince 27 Jul 2017

Finally, as regards the assertion by certain interested parties that the measure at issue does not create any ‘clear breach of the principle of equal treatment’, the Commission would point out that the fact that a measure does not create any ‘clear breach of the principle of equal treatment’ in French law does not mean that it derives directly from the intrinsic basic or guiding principles of the reference system or is the result of inherent mechanisms necessary for the functioning and effectiveness of the system (***) [See judgment of the Court of Justice of 8 September 2011, Paint Graphos and Others, Joined Cases C-78/08 to C-80/08, EU:C:2011:550, paragraph 69.] within the meaning of State aid law. As found in the decision of the Constitutional Council [Decision No 2012-238 QPC, 20 April 2012, Journal officiel de la République française, 21 April 2012, p. 7198.], the evaluation of the principle of equality in French law takes into consideration the objectives pursued by the derogating measure, i.e. objectives of generalinterest extrinsic to the tax system, which cannot be used at the stage of justification by the nature and general scheme of the tax system. Although objectives extrinsic to the system may possibly be taken into account at the stage of the assessment of the compatibility of aid, they do not permit justification of the selectivity of a derogation or, therefore, demonstration of the absence of State aid. In addition, the decision of the Constitutional Council mentioned by the interested parties does not concern the ministerial decisions exempting the ports from corporate tax, but a legislative text exempting certain sports meetings from a tax with a different intrinsic logic to that of corporate tax.

  • Judgment of the Court (First Chamber) of 8 September 2011. Ministero dell’Economia e delle Finanze and Agenzia delle Entrate v Paint GraphosDecision

    8 Sep 2011 · 62008CJ0078

  • celex=31978D0008
  • ecli=ECLI:ES:C:2011:550