42 4. COMMENTS BY INTERESTED PARTIES, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1074

In forcesince 19 Jan 2015

Fourth, concerning the state aid assessment in the opening decision, CSTP argued that the market for public transport in Italy in the period in question was not open to competition from undertakings established in other Member States. CSTP therefore concluded that there was no effect on trade or distortion of competition. Likewise, in view of the current organisation of the local public transport service based on the unilateral, exclusive concessions of certain routes, the compensation was not likely to distort competition. Furthermore, the standard cost/km was imposed by the Region and accepted by the concessionaire together with all the other PSOs, so there would therefore be no advantage. The tariff obligation, unlike the obligations to operate and carry, is not affected by any differentiation of the company’s transport activities. Therefore, CSTP considered that at least three of the conditions laid down by the CJEU for identifying state aid were not met in the case at issue.