15 2. DESCRIPTION OF THE MEASURE › 2.2. THE JUDGMENTS OF THE CONSIGLIO DI STATO, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1074

In forcesince 19 Jan 2015

By order (ordinanza) No 8736/2010 of 13 December 2010, the Consiglio di Stato appointed an expert to undertake that task. According to the Italian authorities, that expert was also unable to determine the amount to be compensated and it was only with the help of an additional expert, appointed by the Consiglio di Stato by order No 5897/2011 of 7 November 2011, that a specific amount of compensation was calculated using an ‘inductive method’, as prescribed by the Consiglio di Stato by order No 3244/2011 of 25 July 2011. On the basis of those calculations, the experts concluded that CSTP was undercompensated only for 1998 as a result of the application of the formula provided in Article 11 of Regulation (EEC) No 1191/69 (i.e. tariff obligation). The experts could not use an inductive method to calculate the undercompensation (if any) on the basis of Article 10 (i.e. obligation to operate or carry) of the same Regulation because of the lack of reliable data and the risk that such a method would duplicate the compensation calculated under Article 11. Implicitly, the experts thus assumed that a tariff obligation had been imposed on CSTP.

  • celex=31969R1191