CSTP considered that the accounting documents supplied by it could not be claimed to be insufficient to support the compensation claim merely because they consisted of annual financial statements and ‘E forms’ [Modelli E, namely the documents based on the accounts of the company containing the information necessary for the annual calculation of the public contribution.] and were not accompanied by full copies of the underlying accounting and administrative entries (accounting register, ledgers, invoices issued and received, ticket receipts, etc.). According to CSTP, this argument could easily be countered by noting that the Region had accepted the same data in the past, considering them reliable. Furthermore, the requirement to keep full accounting and administrative documentation for the period in question has now expired, and it is hence objectively difficult to demand copies at present. Therefore, it is fully appropriate to reconstruct the amount of compensation due via an inductive approach, as prescribed by the Consiglio di Stato. Finally the financial statements had been duly certified and their correctness and truthfulness had never been called into question. In conclusion, the accounts submitted by CSTP were clearly sufficient for calculating the compensation in full compliance with the requirements of Regulation (EEC) No 1191/69.
40 4. COMMENTS BY INTERESTED PARTIES, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1074
In forcesince 19 Jan 2015
- celex=31969R1191