As to whether A NOVO, as a wholly owned subsidiary of the French undertaking A NOVO SA, whose turnover is some EUR 350 million, can qualify as a company in difficulty eligible for rescue and restructuring support, Spain claimed that the firm’s difficulties were intrinsic and too serious to be dealt with by the Group itself. They were intrinsic because exclusively linked to the activities of A NOVO and, in particular, to its shift from manufacturing to services. They did not result from any cost allocations within the group. Furthermore, the firm’s financial difficulties were too serious for the group itself to overcome. The 2008 and 2009 profit and cash flow results for the A NOVO Group SA and A NOVO Comlink Spain show that towards the end of 2008, when the difficulties of A NOVO began to call for a rescue operation, the parent company was itself under financial pressure:
(EUR million)
A NOVO Group SA (France) | A NOVO (Spain)
2008 | 2009 | 2008 | 2009
Sales | 350 | 366 | 14,9 | 15,5
Profits | –17 | 12 | –3,9 | –0,3
Own resources | 45 | 53 | 0 | 1,8
Short-term loans | 28 | 18 | 3,4 | 2
Long-term loans | 56 | 51 | 0,6 | 0,7
Cash flow | –0,3 | 2 | –0,6 | –0,9
Assets | 230 | 225 | 14,2 | 13,4
The Group’s losses of EUR 17 million in 2008 were also caused by a series of commitments towards A NOVO Spain. The A NOVO Group made very significant contributions to its Spanish subsidiary: EUR 2123 million in 2006 and EUR 2060 million in 2009. Further pressure arose in 2009 from the need to reschedule the French Group’s debts.