62 4. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 4.1. Application of Article 87(1) of the Treaty, Decision_act (EU) 2011/693

In forcesince 21 Dec 2005

The second condition of Article 87(1) relates to the possibility of the measures favouring specific beneficiaries. It needs to be determined, firstly, whether the beneficiary companies derive an economic benefit and, secondly, whether this benefit is granted to a specific type of company. The aid clearly provides economic benefits for coalmining companies in that there is a direct subsidisation which covers current expenses that these companies would normally have to bear themselves. These expenses consist of the difference between the production costs and the foreseeable revenue plus the costs arising from the restructuring, and the coalmining companies benefit from the fact that they are partly compensated for these costs. Moreover, the measures in question are aimed solely at coalmining companies in Spain. They therefore favour certain companies over their competitors, i.e. they are selective.