The investigation revealed that Agronova had strong interpersonal and operational links to at least one other undisclosed company active in the trading and marketing of fertiliser products. It was found that the same and only persons operating Agronova were in fact also involved in the activities of this trading company. In particular, the evidence available showed that both companies shared a common manager and a common officer during most of the RIP, while a third person (who was at the same time found to be the President of the trading company in question), although not formally employed by Agronova, was in fact carrying out its daily trading business including the conduct during the verification visit on behalf of Agronova where he was presented as an advisor of Agronova. In addition to the strong interpersonal links, it was found that both companies were operating from the same office, employing the same secretary and using the same computers and office equipment during almost the entirety of the RIP. Agronova did not reveal the existence and operations of this other trading company neither in its response to the questionnaire nor at the time of the verification visit. The Commission’s request for additional information in order to clarify the situation was only partly satisfied by the applicant since it did not, inter alia, disclose the precise ownership of the trading company nor its detailed activities. The information provided was therefore considered insufficient.
14 C. RESULTS OF THE INVESTIGATION › 1. Workability of the undertaking › 1.1. High risk of cross-compensation through an undisclosed trading company, Council Implementing Regulation (EU) No 856/2010 of 27 September 2010 terminating the pa…
In force