X. ASSESSMENT, Decision_act (EU) 2009/944

In forcesince 13 Jul 2009
(60)

While the matter was being examined, the Italian authorities used a series of arguments to defend their position that the scheme did not contain elements of State aid:

on the basis of the political agreement reached by the Council and the Commission at the Ecofin Council on 19 March 2003, derogations from a general [tax] system or differences within it that were justified by the nature or general characteristics of the tax system did not constitute State aid. Furthermore, in Italy the exemptions were consistent with the Italian tax system because they were applicable to all products grown in glasshouses and because the quantities of fuel exempted from excise duties were apportioned on the basis of the activity carried out,

on the basis of the estimates and data available, the scheme in question ‘was not detrimental to the proper functioning of the internal market and would not result in distortions of competition’ (see recitals 30 and 31),

the exemptions were neither selective nor such as to distort competition.