VI. SECOND OPENING OF THE PROCEDURE UNDER ARTICLE 88(2) OF THE TREATY (CASE C 5/05), Decision_act (EU) 2009/944

In forcesince 13 Jul 2009
(34)

The Commission initiated a second procedure under Article 88(2) of the Treaty after obtaining information demonstrating that the excise duty exemption enjoyed by glasshouse growers was actually significantly higher than that analysed when the procedure was first opened. The doubts expressed when the procedure was first opened, the causes of which included the fact that the Italian authorities had not replied to the information injunction sent to them, were corroborated by those authorities’ reaction to the initial opening of the procedure. Essentially, the doubts expressed by the Commission when the procedure was opened for the second time were based on the following considerations:

(a)

the Italian authorities considered that, regardless of their level, excise duty exemptions on fuels did not constitute State aid but rather tax measures justified by the nature of the system of which they were part. However, they did not supply any information in support of this argument;

(b)

the Italian authorities further argued that the excise duty exemption did not distort competition, inasmuch as nursery growers were free to avail themselves of the exemption by practising greenhouse growing. This argument appears doubtful, inasmuch as the exemption was aimed not at encouraging a changeover to glasshouse growing, but rather to provide greenhouse growers who were already in business with relief from a financial burden linked to exercise of their activity;

(c)

again as regards the issue of distortion of competition, the Italian authorities asserted that, according to the official data available to them, the total exemption granted to glasshouse growers did not distort competition. In the Commission’s view, it is unclear how the Italian authorities can make such an argument since, in their reply sent by telex to the Commission on 10 June 2004 (see recital 14 above), they stated that they could not supply precise data on the sums that glasshouse growers could save as a result of the total exemption;

(d)

although the Italian authorities asserted that there were no elements of State aid, they failed to indicate which rule of competition would, in their opinion, support the compatibility with the common market of the total excise duty exemption;

(e)

the fact that the exemptions were granted contrary to Directives 92/81/EEC and 2003/96/EC could not be ruled out.