As regards in particular point 51.2(b) of the guidelines, on the basis of which derogations for firms must have been decided on when the tax was adopted, the Italian authorities referred to Commission Decision C(2005) 4436 of 7 December 2005. That decision provides that ‘the excise taxes concerned may not have had an explicit environmental purpose from the outset and the exemptions were decided on […] well before the 2001 environmental aid guidelines became applicable. Therefore, their situation may be considered as if they had been decided at the time the excise tax was adopted. Consequently, in accordance with point 51.2 of the guidelines, the provisions in point 51.1 may be applied to the exemptions to be assessed in this decision’. The Italian authorities added that the excise duty reductions were decided on following a change in the economic situation (in particular an exponential rise in the price of oil) that placed glasshouse growers in a particularly difficult competitive situation as compared to farmers growing crops outdoors and led the authorities in other countries to adopt measures in favour of glasshouse growers and the fisheries sector. The authorities indicated that, in the period under consideration, the price of diesel for heating varied as follows: + 37 % in 1999-2000, + 26 % in 1999-2001 and + 26 % in 1999-2002. Meanwhile the price structure was as follows (annual average in EUR per litre):
EUR per litre
Price net of tax | Tax | Consumer price
1999 | 0,217 | 0,524 | 0,741
2000 | 0,342 | 0,523 | 0,865
2001 | 0,317 | 0,504 | 0,821
2002 | 0,292 | 0,542 | 0,834
2003 | 0,314 | 0,547 | 0,861
2004 | 0,354 | 0,555 | 0,909