As for the argument that the exemptions are justified by the nature or general characteristics of the tax system, the Commission takes the view that specific excise duty exemptions limited to a given type of production (in the present case, glasshouse growing, which received higher exemptions than growing outdoors) cannot be justified by the nature and logic of the tax system when Community law requires, in principle, the Member States to impose excise duties [See Commission Decision 2006/323/EC (OJ L 119, 4.5.2006, p. 12).]. The same consideration applies when Community law does not provide for the exemptions in question to be granted. The argument that the exemptions are valid for all products grown in glasshouses is not relevant in this case, since entire branches of the agricultural production sector received lower exemptions than those granted to glasshouse growers and if, as the Italian authorities assert, the quantities of exempted fuel were apportioned on the basis of the activity carried out, the logic of the tax system would have required the exemption to be the same for all activities based on the use of diesel.
62 X. ASSESSMENT, Decision_act (EU) 2009/944
In forcesince 13 Jul 2009
- celex=32009D0323