In the case under examination, the Commission considers that the aid is not degressive because, in the light of the various articles of the Finance Laws that provided for the excise duty exemption, the exemption was partial until 31 December 2000 and then total for each of the periods referred to in recital 27 above. In addition, the aid was not temporary since, in reality, with the exception of the second half of 2001, the exemptions were permanent for the entire period considered. Although the Italian authorities certainly referred to the existence of a difficult competitive situation (see recital 42 above), they did not supply information proving the loss of competitiveness. Lastly, it appears implausible that a system of exemptions which, by definition, makes fuels cheaper, could lead the beneficiaries to reduce their use of the inputs concerned (be it glasshouses or, by extension, the fuels themselves, if they are regarded as inputs).
88 X. ASSESSMENT, Decision_act (EU) 2009/944
In forcesince 13 Jul 2009