101 X. ASSESSMENT, Decision_act (EU) 2009/944

In forcesince 13 Jul 2009cited 1×

It is not possible to accept the argument put forward by the Italian authorities that the Commission should carry out its analysis as if the exemptions had been decided on when the tax was introduced. In effect, the Italian authorities referred to Commission Decision C(2005) 4436 (see recital 42 above). In this Decision (see, in particular, recital 74 thereof), the Commission based its findings on the fact that the exemptions had been decided on well before the 2001 environmental aid guidelines became applicable. However, in the case under examination, it must be noted that the first exemptions date back to October 2000, i.e. shortly before these guidelines became applicable. It must be stressed that at no stage did the Italian authorities rely on exemptions previously granted.

  • Arrêt du Tribunal (septième chambre) du 13 septembre 2012. République italienne contre Commission européenne.Decision

    13 Sep 2012 · 62009TJ0379