56 4. COMMENTS FROM GERMANY FOLLOWING THE OPENING DECISION, Decision_act (EU) 2009/775

In forcesince 21 Oct 2008

As regards the assessment of the first measure, Germany therefore claims that only the losses initially estimated should be considered. That would mean losses of EUR 3,5 billion in a worst-case and EUR [< 2,5] billion in a mid-case scenario. Germany argues that a private investor would compare the direct cost of an insolvency of IKB, which would have been EUR 1,5 billion, stemming from maintaining IKB’s book value of about EUR 620 million (based on German accounting rules) [This value was below IKB’s stock market value and even below the stock market value on 27 July 2007.] and the cost of writing off about EUR 850 million in loans which IKB had distributed to third parties in the context of KfW’s development business [This corresponds to [> 15] % default of the overall amount of loans distributed by IKB on behalf of KfW, assuming that in the case of an insolvency of IKB, these loans would partially default, which would be directly to the detriment of KfW.]. In addition, Germany claims the insolvency of IKB would produce second-round effects resulting in the write-off of additional loans granted as part of credits from the development activities of at least EUR 1,1 billion and an increased cost of refinancing. Finally, KfW’s reputation would have suffered too.