In fact, the Member States and beneficiaries failed to identify any overall logic of their respective tax systems. On the basis of the information available to the Commission, it is clear that the reasons for granting the aid derive rather from the circumstances of alumina production in the specific regions concerned. These arguments do not derive from the nature and logic of the respective domestic tax systems. Therefore, the Commission concludes that the exemptions remain highly selective, favouring the production of a specific product and, de facto, specific undertakings and they cannot be justified within the logic of the domestic tax systems.
40 5 ASSESSMENT › 5.2 Existence of State aid as from 1 January 2004, Decision_act (EU) 2007/375
In forcesince 7 Feb 2007cited 1×
Arrêt du Tribunal (première chambre) du 17 septembre 2019. République italienne et Eurallumina SpA contre Commission européenne.Decision
Eurallumina fait, en substance, grief à la Commission d’avoir commis une erreur dans l’application de la directive 2003/96. En effet, aux considérants 29 à 40 de la décision attaquée, elle aurait estimé que la directive 2003/96 …
17 Sep 2019 · 62007TJ0119