99 7. RECOVERY OF THE AID › 7.1. Recovery of the incompatible aid granted until 2 February 2002, Decision_act (EU) 2006/323

In forcesince 7 Dec 2005

Ordering the recovery of the incompatible aid for the period until 2 February 2002 would also breach the principle of legal certainty under the exceptional circumstances of this specific case. According to the case-law, that principle is breached when the circumstances of uncertainty and lack of clarity led to the creation of an equivocal situation which the Commission should have clarified before it could take any action to order recovery [Judgement of 1 July 2004 in Case T-308/00, Salzgitter AG v. Commission, not yet reported, paragraph 180.]. The circumstances in this case did lead to an equivocal situation, not only for the beneficiary, but also for the Member States, which were entitled to rely on the wording of Decisions 92/510/EEC, 93/697/EC, 96/273/EC, 97/425/EC, 1999/255/EC, 1999/880/EC and 2001/224/EC.

  • Decision_act (EU) 2001/224Law

  • case:eu=T-308/00 (several documents carry this name)
  • celex=31992D0510
  • celex=31993D0697
  • celex=31996D0273
  • celex=31997D0425
  • celex=31999D0255
  • celex=31999D0880
  • num:eu=1992/510
  • num:eu=1993/697
  • num:eu=1996/273