In the decisions by which the Commission initiated the procedure laid down in Article 88(2) of the Treaty [See footnote 1.], the Commission raised doubts as to whether the aids could be found compatible with the common market under Article 87(3)(a) of the Treaty. The Italian and Irish authorities did not bring forward any elements in order to alleviate those doubts. They did not demonstrate the existence of particular handicaps nor did they gauge their importance in order to justify the granting of operating aid. High energy prices and competition from third-country imports, in particular, do not have a regional character. Even if the non-availability of natural gas were to be a particular regional handicap of the regions concerned, which has not been proven, Ireland and Italy have not gauged the importance of any such handicap to justify the level of aid. The Italian legislation, which according to Eurallumina results in additional costs, may partly have a regional character as Sardinia has been declared an area of high risk of environmental crisis but, in general, cannot be considered as a particular handicap for the region. In any event, it appears that the exemptions in question in this case are not limited in time nor progressively reduced as the guidelines require. Therefore the aid can not be found to be compatible with the common market on the ground that it facilitates the development of certain regions.
80 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.3. Compatibility of the new aid granted until 31 December 2003 › 6.3.2. Compatibility of the new aid pursuant to Article 87(3)(a) of the Treaty, Decision_act (EU) 2006/323
In forcesince 7 Dec 2005cited 1×
Arrêt du Tribunal (première chambre) du 17 septembre 2019. République italienne et Eurallumina SpA contre Commission européenne.Decision
Aux considérants 78, 79 et 80 de la décision alumine I, la Commission avait notamment formulé les appréciations suivantes : « 78 En ce qui concerne la dérogation prévue à l’article 87, paragraphe 3, [sous] a), [CE], qui vise les …
17 Sep 2019 · 62007TJ0119