63 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.1. Existence of State aid until 31 December 2003, Decision_act (EU) 2006/323

In forcesince 7 Dec 2005cited 1×

Measures that do not favour certain undertakings do not fall within the definition of State aid in Article 87(1), but, in the absence of selectivity, must be considered as general measures. According to the jurisprudence of the Court of Justice of the European Communities general measures must be effectively open to all firms on an equal access basis, and they must not de facto be reduced in scope through, for example, the discretionary power of the State to grant them, or through other factors that restrict their practical effect. The Commission explained the notion of general measures a.o. in a Staff Working Paper which was discussed in the meeting of the Council Working Party on 14 November 2002. The Working Paper continues with an explanation under which conditions aid in the form of tax measures can be found compatible with the common market. The minutes of the Council meeting of 27 October 2003, when Directive 2003/96/EC was adopted, expressly refer to the explanations given during the meeting of the Council Working Party on 14 November 2002. In the case at hand, however, the exemptions only apply to companies that produce alumina and in practice, in each Member State there is only one company benefiting from the exemption at stake: Aughinish in the Shannon region, Eurallumina in Sardinia and Alcan in Gardanne. As long as the Council Decisions were binding, the exemptions were regionally selective, because these Decisions only authorised exemptions in certain regions and potential investors interested to make investments in alumina production in other regions could not be sure to receive similar treatment. The selection of the regions has no relationship whatsoever with the internal logic of the national tax systems at stake.

  • Order of the Court (Seventh Chamber) of 7 December 2017. Eurallumina SpA v European Commission.Decision

    In the present instance, in order to reject the Italian Republic’s argument that the Commission had erred in law in the decision at issue in finding that the exemption at issue was selective when the fact that only Eurallumina’s …

    7 Dec 2017 · 62016CO0323