In their comments, the beneficiaries submitted that they had undertaken significant environmental investments in return for the exemptions. However, there is no evidence that the beneficiaries concluded any agreements with the Member States concerned whereby they committed to achieve environmental protection objectives during the period for which the exemptions applied. Nor were the tax exemptions subject to conditions that would ensure the same effect as such agreements and commitments. Furthermore it appears that the environmental investments did not go beyond what was necessary to comply with relevant legislation or beyond what was feasible and economical from a commercial point of view. As a consequence, the conditions for applying point 51.1(a) of the 2001 guidelines on State aid for environmental protection are not fulfilled and only the provisions of point 51.1(b) are applicable in this case.
75 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.3. Compatibility of the new aid granted until 31 December 2003 › 6.3.1. Compatibility under the rules for environmental aid, Decision_act (EU) 2006/323
Arrêt du Tribunal (première chambre) du 17 septembre 2019. République italienne et Eurallumina SpA contre Commission européenne.Decision
Au considérant 75 de la décision alumine I, la Commission a indiqué ce qui suit : « 75 Dans leurs observations, les bénéficiaires ont fait valoir qu’ils avaient réalisé des investissements écologiques importants en contrepartie …
17 Sep 2019 · 62007TJ0119
Judgment of the General Court (First Chamber) of 17 September 2019. Ireland and Aughinish Alumina Ltd v European Commission.Decision
It is common ground that, in the procedure in Case T‑130/07, although it claims that it had ‘accepted’ environmental obligations, Aughinish neither alleged nor, a fortiori, demonstrated that it had provided the Commission with …
17 Sep 2019 · 62007TJ0129