65 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.2. New aid, not existing aid, Decision_act (EU) 2006/323

In forcesince 7 Dec 2005

The aid granted by France and Italy, does not constitute existing aid in the meaning of Article 1(b) of Regulation (EC) No 659/1999 and the aid granted by Ireland constitutes existing aid only to a limited extent. First of all, the aid measures did not exist prior to the entry into force of the Treaty in the Member States concerned. This is perfectly clear in the case of France and Italy. As regards Ireland, the aid was not granted before accession. In 1970, the Industrial Development Authority (IDA) wrote to Alcan that the Irish legislation in force at that time provided for ‘(a) import of … operating supplies free of duty and (b) freedom from domestic tax for raw materials for processing and exports’. The letter further explained that (underlining added) ‘while I cannot give a formal commitment that there will be no change in the legislation I am satisfied that, in view of the vital importance of exports to the Irish economy, there is no possibility of the legislation being changed, in the foreseeable future, to the detriment of the Alcan project’. The IDA proceeds by stressing the reputation of the Irish Government in this respect. Such wording should not be confused with binding commitments. Further assurances were given in a letter dated 14 January 1974, that is to say, after the accession of Ireland. However, the fiscal advantages in force in 1970 were substantially modified or even abolished after accession and by 1980 a minimum of IEP 1,53 per hectolitre was to be paid on heavy oil used for a purpose other than combustion in the engine of a motor vehicle. The current exemption from the excise duty payable on fuel oil used for the manufacture of alumina, which differs substantially in its nature, form and scope from the legislation in force in 1970, was only established by order of 12 May 1983 and is applicable to oil imported or delivered from a refinery or bonded warehouse on or after 13 May 1983. Therefore, it was established well after the date on which the Treaty became applicable in Ireland. In addition, in its letter of 6 May 1983, Ireland accepted the arguments of the Commission that the aid was notifiable.

  • celex=31999R0659