With the exception of Decision 2001/224/EC none of the decisions referred to in recitals (1), (2) and (3) mentioned any possible contradiction with the State aid rules nor did they make any reference to the obligation to notify. Furthermore, the preamble to Decision 92/510/EEC states that ‘it is accepted by the Commission and by all Member States that these exemptions are well founded in terms of specific policies and do not give rise to distortions of competition or interfere with the working of the internal market’. The same wording is used in Decisions 93/697/EC and 96/273/EC. Decisions 97/425/EC, 99/255/EC and 99/880/EC refer to the fact that ‘the exemptions and reductions will be regularly reviewed by the Commission to ensure that they are compatible with the operation of the internal market and other objectives of the Treaty’ (underlining added). From this wording it appears that one of the elements of the definition of State aid in Article 87 of the Treaty, namely the distortion of competition, is missing. The fifth recital in the preamble to Decision 2001/224/EC made it clear for the first time that, notwithstanding the authorisation given by the Council in the context of Council Directive 92/81EEC of 19 October 1992 on the harmonisation of the structures of excise duties on mineral oils [OJ L 316, 31.10.1992, p. 12.], the national measures at stake were to be notified to the Commission in accordance with Article 88(3) EC, when they constituted State aid. Nevertheless, in view of the series of previous exemptions, and the fact that Decision 2001/224/EC itself was adopted on the basis of a proposal from the Commission, some ambiguity remained for the Member States and beneficiaries in the absence of further Commission's action relative to State aid.
97 7. RECOVERY OF THE AID › 7.1. Recovery of the incompatible aid granted until 2 February 2002, Decision_act (EU) 2006/323
In forcesince 7 Dec 2005
- celex=31992D0051
- celex=31992D0510
- celex=31992L0081
- celex=31993D0697
- celex=31996D0273
- celex=31997D0425
- celex=31999D0255
- celex=31999D0880
- num:eu=1992/81
- num:eu=1993/697