91 6. ASSESSMENT › 6.4. Preliminary assessment of the measures for the period since 1.1.2004, Decision_act (EU) 2006/323

In forcesince 7 Dec 2005

In such a case, the new legal situation created by Directive 2003/96/EC is also relevant for the assessment of the compatibility of such measures with the common market. Since taxation of mineral oils used for dual uses, non-fuel uses and mineralogical processes is now outside the scope of harmonised Community measures, the exemptions now concern domestic taxes imposed in the absence of a Community tax within the meaning of point 51.1(b), second indent, of the 2001 Guidelines on State aid for environmental protection. That provision requires benefiting companies to pay a significant proportion of the national tax. The reason for that is to leave them with an incentive to improve their environmental performance. This follows from the wording of point 51.1(b), first indent, of the guidelines, which allows for tax reductions from a harmonised tax if the beneficiaries pay more than the Community minimum rates ‘in order to provide firms with an incentive to improve environmental protection’. This also applies where the national tax is significantly higher than comparable taxes in (some) other Member States, as was the case in Italy. In the practice of the Commission, it has become clear that, in general 20 %, or the Community minimum that applies to energy uses that do fall within the scope of Directive 2003/96/EC (EUR 15 per tonne), which ever is the lowest, can be regarded as a significant proportion [See e.g. Commission Decision of 30.6.2004 in Case C 42/2003 (OJ L 165, 25.6.2005, p. 21), decision of 13.2.2002 in Case N449/01 (OJ C 137, 8.6.2002, p. 24), decision of 11.12.2002 in Case N74/A/2002 (OJ C 104, 30.4.2003, p. 9) and decision of 11.12.2001 in cases NN3A/2001 and NN4A/2001 (OJ C 104, 30.4.2003). These cases are particularly relevant, as they also concerned exemptions from energy taxes. An indication as to what the Commission might consider as too low on the other hand is contained in the Commission Decision on the partial refund of the waste water tax in Denmark, decision of 3.4.2002 in case NN30/A-C/2001 (OJ C 292, 27.11.2002, p. 6).]. Therefore, at this stage, the Commission considers that only the exemption beyond a level of 20 % of the domestic tax or beyond EUR 15 per tonne, whichever is the lowest, could be considered compatible; the exemption up to the level of 20 %, or up to EUR 15 per tonne, would then constitute incompatible aid.