II. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE AID MEASURES › Subsidies paid in respect of public service obligations › The annual balancing subsidy, Decision_act (EU) 2005/163

In forcesince 16 Mar 2004
(43)

The amount of the subsidy paid to the regional companies of the Tirrenia Group pursuant to the 1991 public service agreements has evolved as follows [Data taken from the PricewaterhouseCoopers study Valutazione dei criteri di predisposizione dei conti economici gestionali per linea e stagionalità relativi agli esercizi 1992-1999, supplemented by the Italian authorities to include the years 2000 and 2001. The study reproduces the analytical accounts of the Tirrenia Group companies and assesses the operating costs and revenue for each of the routes.]:

ADRIATICA

(in ITL million)

YEAR | (A) OPERATING COSTS | (B) OPERATING REVENUE |

(C) NET LOSS (accumulated losses minus accumulated revenue)

(A — B)

RETURN ON CAPITAL INVESTED | AMOUNT OF ANNUAL SUBSIDY

1992 | – 127018 | 64772 | – 62772 | 8258 | 70504

1993 | – 124191 | 79716 | – 44475 | 10615 | 55090

1994 | – 158533 | 80324 | – 78209 | 7819 | 86028

1995 | – 166334 | 95114 | – 71220 | 9304 | 80524

1996 | – 170095 | 95422 | – 74673 | 7935 | 82608

1997 | – 174331 | 94995 | – 79336 | 5788 | 85124

1998 | – 175809 | 114210 | – 61599 | 5271 | 66870

1999 | – 151109 | 126403 | – 24706 | 3646 | 28352

2000 | – 137255 | 109786 | – 27469 | 4377 | 31846

2001 | – 183820 | 155616 | – 28204 | 6147 | 34351

The sizeable variations in the amount of the annual subsidy (last column) are explained by the fluctuations in the net operating costs (column C) of the international connections with Albania, Yugoslavia and Croatia, on which services were interrupted on account of the political situation in the Balkans. Conversely, the net operating costs and the annual subsidy requirement for the cabotage connections in the upper Adriatic and with the Tremiti archipelago generally remained stable between 1992 and 2001. In addition, the suspension of services to Greece at the end of 1999 brought an appreciable reduction in operating costs and thus in the size of the balancing subsidy.

SAREMAR

(in ITL million)

YEAR | (A) OPERATING COSTS | (B) OPERATING REVENUE |

(C) NET LOSS (accumulated losses minus accumulated revenue)

(A — B)

RETURN ON CAPITAL INVESTED | AMOUNT OF ANNUAL SUBSIDY

1992 | – 33519,0 | 7464,0 | – 26055,0 | 1342,0 | 27397,0

1993 | – 35938,0 | 8365,0 | – 27573,0 | 2641,0 | 30214,0

1994 | – 35295,2 | 9383,8 | – 25911,4 | 1606,2 | 27517,6

1995 | – 34605,7 | 11396,6 | – 23209,1 | 1781,6 | 24990,7

1996 | – 34972,8 | 11533,5 | – 23439,3 | 1560,4 | 24999,7

1997 | – 36653,4 | 11746,7 | – 24906,7 | 1172,8 | 26079,5

1998 | – 39602,0 | 11744,0 | – 27858,0 | 973,0 | 28831,0

1999 | – 40218,8 | 12425,6 | – 27793,2 | 738,8 | 28532,0

2000 | – 36300,0 | 12652,0 | – 23648,0 | 828,0 | 24476,0

2001 | – 31105,6 | 12487,0 | – 17649,5 | 1094,9 | 18725,1

The relatively stable level of the annual subsidy (last column) reflects the nature of the market on which Saremar operates, i.e. a local market meeting the mobility requirements of the island communities. The services the company provides have remained largely unchanged — in terms of frequency and timetables — since the public service agreement entered into force [In 1992 Saremar carried out a total of 18000 trips on the four routes it operates. In 2000 the number of trips was around 20000.] and are virtually unchanged throughout any given year.

TOREMAR

(in ITL million)

YEAR | (A) OPERATING COSTS | (B) OPERATING REVENUE |

(C) NET LOSS (accumulated losses minus accumulated revenue)

(A — B)

RETURN ON CAPITAL INVESTED | AMOUNT OF ANNUAL SUBSIDY

1992 | – 43511,0 | 27406,0 | – 16105,0 | 1367,0 | 17472,0

1993 | – 44907,0 | 30750,0 | – 14157,0 | 2145,0 | 16302,0

1994 | – 47696,6 | 32759,0 | – 14937,0 | 1312,1 | 16249,1

1995 | – 47900,0 | 32000,0 | – 15900,0 | 1400,0 | 17300,0

1996 | – 50516,1 | 32483,3 | – 18032,8 | 1285,0 | 19317,8

1997 | – 48900,0 | 31200,0 | – 17700,0 | 900,0 | 18600,0

1998 | – 50801,0 | 29996,0 | – 20805,0 | 718,0 | 21523,0

1999 | – 47840,1 | 32362,0 | – 15478,1 | 588,1 | 16066,2

2000 | – 45675,0 | 34577,0 | – 11098,0 | 1993,0 | 13091,0

2001 | – 44903,1 | 35573,5 | – 9329,6 | 3033,5 | 12363,2

The essentially local market on which Toremar operates explains the relatively stable level of the annual subsidy over the years (last column). The services the public company provided in 2000 were the same — in terms of frequency and timetables — as those provided in 1992 [In 2000 the company carried out a total of 9097 trips on its network of routes, compared with 8300 in 1992.] and are unchanged throughout the year irrespective of seasonal variations in demand.

SIREMAR

(in ITL million)

YEAR | (A) OPERATING COSTS | (B) OPERATING REVENUE |

(C) NET LOSS (accumulated losses minus accumulated revenue)

(A — B)

RETURN ON CAPITAL INVESTED | AMOUNT OF ANNUAL SUBSIDY

1992 | – 79543,0 | 26903,0 | – 52640,0 | 2874,0 | 55514,0

1993 | – 75845,0 | 30444,0 | – 45401,0 | 5334,0 | 50735,0

1994 | – 78549,7 | 32845,7 | – 45704,0 | 3336,0 | 49040,0

1995 | – 80947,5 | 33847,0 | – 47100,5 | 4363,7 | 51464,2

1996 | – 85934,6 | 32724,0 | – 53210,6 | 3888,4 | 57099,0

1997 | – 97536,9 | 35203,2 | – 62333,4 | 3155,1 | 65488,5

1998 | – 106563,1 | 37244,8 | – 69318,3 | 2599,3 | 71917,6

1999 | – 110611,1 | 40274,2 | – 70336,9 | 2211,2 | 72548,1

2000 | – 102881,0 | 43335,0 | – 59546,0 | 3940,0 | 63486,0

2001 | – 106490,0 | 47314,4 | – 59175,6 | 4249,9 | 63425,5

The services provided by Siremar are comparable in nature to those provided by Saremar and Toremar: supply has been stable since the public service agreement entered into force [In 2000 Siremar carried out a total of 11910 trips on its various routes; in 1992 it carried out 11919.] and is scarcely affected by seasonal variations. The company’s high operating costs, entailing a huge annual subsidy, are explained in particular by the number of routes it operates (18 scheduled routes) in order to meet the mobility requirements of the inhabitants of the 14 islands situated off Sicily. This large number of scheduled services means that major operating costs (staff, fuel, maintenance, etc.) are incurred in guaranteeing the large number of trips the company carries out each year [In 2000 the company carried out a total of 11900 trips on 18 scheduled routes (11700 in 1992).].

CAREMAR

(in ITL million)

YEAR | (A) OPERATING COSTS | (B) OPERATING REVENUE |

(C) NET LOSS (accumulated losses minus accumulated revenue)

(A — B)

RETURN ON CAPITAL INVESTED | AMOUNT OF ANNUAL SUBSIDY

1992 | – 59987,0 | 20543,0 | – 39444,0 | 26,0 | 39470,0

1993 | – 63737,0 | 22810,0 | – 40927,0 | 1538,0 | 42465,0

1994 | – 69365,7 | 25470,0 | – 43894,8 | 1690,0 | 45584,8

1995 | – 71389,6 | 24519,9 | – 46869,7 | 2173,2 | 49042,9

1996 | – 71404,3 | 26613,7 | – 44790,6 | 1867,4 | 46658,0

1997 | – 73752,0 | 30420,0 | – 43332,0 | 1516,9 | 44848,9

1998 | – 77143,0 | 31920,0 | – 45223,0 | 1287,0 | 46510,0

1999 | – 74172,0 | 30896,5 | – 43275,5 | 986,6 | 44262,3

2000 | – 70114,0 | 32594,0 | – 37520,0 | 2291,0 | 39818,0

2001 | – 68316,8 | 33377,9 | – 34938,9 | 3366,5 | 38305,4

The stability of the annual subsidy is explained by the nature of the network of services Caremar provides; these services have remained largely unchanged since the agreement with the State entered into force [In 2000 the company carried out 12872 trips on 12 routes (15650 in 1992).].

The company’s high operating costs, which are reflected in the level of annual compensation, arise from the number of routes it operates (11) and the frequency of connections.