As to the doubts surrounding the viability of the business plan, and specifically the lack of market information, France describes the market in which SORENI operates as comprising the following activities: repair works for minor damages, preventive maintenance works and major repair works. The main competitors of SORENI, ARNO in Dunkirk and SOBRENA in Brest, are said to compete with SORENI for national and international clients, but not for local clients, which account for between 40 % and 45 % of SORENI’s turnover. France also argues that the existence of a ship-repair activity in a port the size of Le Havre is an indispensable element for the proper functioning of the port as a whole. Since SORENI is the only ship repairer in Le Havre, its existence is, according to France, vital to the port.
31 IV. COMMENTS FROM FRANCE, Decision_act (EU) 2005/90
In forcesince 20 Apr 2004