Recital 31, Decision_act (EU) 2003/192

In forcesince 20 Dec 2001

As to the character of the tax measure in question, the Spanish authorities consider that, since it is not caught by the selectivity requirement laid down in Article 87(1), it cannot be regarded as State aid. It is not selective, in particular since it is applied irrespective of the sector of the economy in which the firms operate and since its purpose, which is to promote the economy as a whole, is not selective as the Commission maintains: the objective, non-discriminatory implementing criteria which it lays down do not transform the firms that meet them into "certain undertakings" within the meaning of Article 87 of the Treaty. In support of their conclusion, the Spanish authorities stress in particular that the measure in question, designed as its name suggests to "promote economic activity", pursues a legitimate economic objective using all the instruments available to a State. In addition, they consider that the non-application of the tax concession either to existing firms or new firms created after 31 December 1994 does not mean that it is selective, since, firstly, the purpose is to promote new activities and, secondly, firms created after that date are not disadvantaged compared with the recipients of the aid. As to the quantitative conditions concerning investment, job-creation and capital, the Spanish authorities consider that these do not mean that the measure is selective, since the conditions, as a result of their horizontal and objective nature, are not discriminatory. As the selectivity requirement is not met, the Spanish authorities conclude that the measure cannot be regarded as State aid, but as a measure of a general nature.