Recital 30, Decision_act (EU) 2003/192

In forcesince 20 Dec 2001

In short, the Spanish authorities consider that, even though, according to the Commission, Provincial Law 18/1993 should be regarded as State aid, it is an existing aid scheme. It has been shown that the Commission was informed, in 1994 or even earlier, of the application of Provincial Law 18/1993 and did not regard it as a State aid; that a change in State aid policy has occurred, since reference is made to existing tax measures in the Member States; and that the said Law has not been amended in any way since it came into force. However, Article 88(1) lays down the compulsory procedure which has to be followed in the case of existing aid: constant review in cooperation with Member States, and not the procedure provided for in Article 88(2). The Regulation also lays down the procedure that should be followed in the case of existing aid schemes: cooperation pursuant to Article 93(1) (currently Article 88(1) of the Treaty) and the proposal of appropriate measures. The Commission, therefore, should annul its decision to initiate the procedure and, if it considers, after a preliminary examination, that the Provincial law does constitute State aid for the purposes of Article 87 of the Treaty, should propose to the Member State in question the measures required in this case by the progressive development or the functioning of the common market.