The Spanish authorities emphasise, firstly, that the tax measure did not constitute an aid when it came into force. As evidence of this they claim that the Commission has known of the existence of the said Provincial Law for many years, since by letter dated 25 May 1994 it informed the Spanish Permanent Representation of a complaint that referred to that Law. They argue that it is clear from the letter that the Commission did not in any way think that the measure put into effect was a State aid, nor that it was appropriate to initiate the procedure provided for in Article 93(2) (currently Article 88(2)) of the Treaty. By letter from the Permanent Representation dated 30 September 1994 the Spanish authorities informed the Commission that, in their opinion, the tax measures did not constitute State aid prohibited by Article 92 of the Treaty, since they were measures of a general nature. Furthermore, by letter to the Permanent Representation dated 19 January 1996, the Commission asked for information about the possible recipients of the measures. Later, by letter dated 6 February 1996, the Tax Coordination Authority (Órgano de coordinación fiscal)(8)) informed the Commission that: "the Basque tax provisions are general in character and are not covered by the concept of State aid". For the rest, the Spanish authorities state that, if the Commission had entertained the slightest suspicion that the provincial law in question constituted State aid within the meaning of Article 87 of the Treaty, it would have been obliged (in accordance with the case-law of the Court of Justice(9)) to initiate the Article 88(2) procedure immediately.
Recital 27, Decision_act (EU) 2003/28
In forcesince 20 Dec 2001