Furthermore, regarding the Spanish authorities' claim that if the Commission considered that the tax holiday was State aid it should have initiated the procedure immediately, on the basis of paragraph 12 in Case C-84/82 (see footnote 9), the Commission would point out that this precedent is not relevant, since it applies only to notified aid schemes. The Commission emphasises that under Article 13(2) of Regulation (EC) No 659/1999 it is not subject, where illegal aid is concerned, to the time limits applicable in the case of notified aid schemes. It also points out that, by letter to the Permanent Representation dated 19 January 1996, it asked for information about the possible recipients of the measure. By fax dated 16 February, confirmed by letter dated 19 February 1996, the Spanish Permanent Representation requested a 15-day extension of the deadline for replying. By letter dated 21 March 1996, the Spanish Permanent Representation requested a further extension of 30 days. Despite these requests, which indicated that a reply might be forthcoming, the Spanish authorities did not answer the Commission's request for information. The Commission would also point out that it initiated a procedure in respect of other similar State aid measures in the form of a reduction of taxable income for certain new firms in Álava (C 49/99) on 29 September 1999. In its final decision of 12 July 2001 it concluded that the said aid was incompatible.
Recital 79, Decision_act (EU) 2003/28
In forcesince 20 Dec 2001
- celex=31999R0659
- case:eu=C-49/99
- case:eu=C-84/82
- celex=31984D0082