Although assessment of the scheme did not require it to do so, the Commission, by way of illustration, examined the specific case of Detursa, the only recipient firm identified (thanks to the complaint submitted by Schütz Ibérica S.L., since the Spanish authorities did not provide the information requested by the Commission concerning the recipients of the tax exemption). According to the information available to the Commission(36), this firm is a subsidiary of the Sotralentz group, whose registered office is at Drulingen in France. The Sotralentz group has two factories, one belonging to the Spanish subsidiary at Comunión, Álava, and the other to the subsidiary at Peterlee in the United Kingdom, which make plastic products, and in particular industrial packaging. On this market, Sotralentz and hence its subsidiary Detursa compete with the German groups Schütz (including its Spanish subsidiary Schütz Ibérica S.L., with two plants in Germany and subsidiaries in France, Italy, the United Kingdom, Norway and Poland) and Werit, the Italian group Mamor and the Finnish group Van Leer. Competition on the IBC (Intermediate Bulk Container) market is clearly cut-throat, as production capacity far exceeds demand. In industrial packaging, competition is worldwide rather than just European: Sotralentz has granted a licence to the Greif Bros Corporation group in the United States of America, and the Schütz group has five factories on the other side of the Atlantic. The Commission therefore thinks that granting Detursa State aid may affect trade between Member States and distort competition, strengthening Detursa's position vis-à-vis competitors like Schütz Ibérica S.L.
Recital 66, Decision_act (EU) 2003/28
In forcesince 20 Dec 2001