While noting the Italian authorities' irrevocable decision to reduce the level of R & D aid by the amount indicated, the Commission considers that ITL 2,823 billion of the remaining investment regarded by Italy as eligible for aid is still intended to support ACB's commercial ambition to extend its range of products in order to penetrate new and more profitable markets. The products already exist and are being produced by ACB's competitors; thus, rather than consisting in the development of new products in special steels, the project is aimed at the modernisation of ACB's products and the plant required to manufacture them.
However the documentation shows that, of the remaining R & D investment, ITL 3,177 billion will be used for the "triplex" process, which allows methane to be injected at high pressure in order to cut argon consumption. This innovatory process has not so far been used industrially by any other European firm in the industry. If it is viable, it should eventually produce savings in energy and decarburisation costs of some 20 % compared with conventional technologies.
Furthermore, the Commission has no doubt that the aid in question will stimulate that part of the research and development programme concerned with the new production process. The aid appears to have been decisive in the company's decision to undertake new engineering research, in addition to its day-to-day research work, to develop the triplex process. To that end, the Commission has analysed the difference between the company's past and present research expenditure, set to rise from 0,5 % to 1,5 % according to forecasts for 1998. At the same time, its full time staff would rise from 9 to 16.
Lastly, the amount earmarked for R & D in 1998 in connection with the notified project is appreciably higher than the average for the sector, which ranges from 0,9 % to 1 %.
Thus the variation in the amount allocated to research (which doubles from 0,5 % to 1 % of turnover), the number of persons assigned to the research programme (which almost doubles from 9 to 16) and the investments in research and development expressed as a percentage of turnover (1,5 % of turnover against an industry average of around 1 %) appear to indicate that, in this case, the condition that aid must serve as an incentive has been satisfied.