In view of the foregoing, it must be concluded that the investment is aimed solely at environmental protection, which means that it is not necessary to deduct any production costs, except for those relating to the investment in renovation of the company's head office and investment in new ecological plant for chemical pickling of steel coil and recovery of the liquid waste (which cannot be released into the environment because of the presence of toxic acids), which could be related to the steelmaking process. It is also clear from information in the Commission's possession that the proposed ecological investments would enable ACB to achieve a far higher level of environmental protection than the statutory minimum.
The independent experts' reports forwarded by the Italian authorities indicated that, as a result of the notified measures, concerning the adaptation of relatively recent plant, ACB would reduce concentration of primary and secondary dusts in the scrubbed fumes to 1 mg/Nm3, the statutory threshold in Italy being 10 mg/Nm3 (Presidential Decree No 203/88 and the Ministerial Decree of 12 July 1990). Nor would the fumes contain any CO or benzofurans (PCDD + PCDF), although Italian law does not impose any standards. The measures would also help to reduce noise levels to below 50 dBA, compared with a legal threshold of 70 dBA. Sulphur dioxide, with a statutory limit of 1700 mg/m3, would be completely eliminated as a result of the measures by means of a non-polluting methane heating system. Lastly, the reduction and filtering of fumes and dust, for which the statutory limit is 150 mg/Nm3, could be cut to under 25 mg/Nm3, and would be totally eliminated from the workplace.
The considerable extra expense involved in environmental investment in addition to that required to bring the plant into line with minimum standards would be justified, in this case, given the location of the steelworks in the middle of the city of Bolzano, which in the past has led people living near the works to form associations to protest about environmental conditions. For this reason ACB decided to invest on a far larger scale than would have been necessary to meet environmental standards, even opting to replace plant which, though by no means obsolete, would not achieve the higher level of environmental protection which the company desired.