, Decision_act (EU) 1998/182

In force

The Italian authorities stated, in their response to the initiation of the procedure, that there is no problem of excess capacity in the haulage sector in the Friuli-Venezia Giulia Region, but rather an undercapacity in vehicle fleets of about 20 % as compared to real needs - in other words, an excessive workload is being placed on existing equipment and personnel in the Region, with a potentially adverse impact on safety.

The Commission therefore considers that the aid in question is not covered by the exemption set out in Article 3(1)(d) of the above Regulation, since it is not part of any reorganisation plan for the sector within the meaning of that provision, and it is not in response to excess capacity in the sector. The conditions for applying that provision are therefore not fulfilled.

In their response to the initiation of the procedure, the Italian authorities argued that the vehicle fleets in the Region are very old, giving rise to detrimental effects as regards atmospheric pollution, noise and safety. This requires a financial input for vehicle replacement, which the operators in the sector would have difficulty in providing. The Italian authorities also maintained that the granting of aid for fleet replacement was apparently not disallowed by the Commission in the past, as evidenced by its answer to parliamentary question No E/1883/96.

The Commission considers that subsidies for vehicle leasing constitute aid of a type which is difficult to reconcile with the common market, notably because it involves an increase in capacity, which is contrary to the spirit of Article 3(1)(d) of Regulation (EEC) No 1107/70. Furthermore, the Commission's answer to the parliamentary question cited by the Italian authorities confined itself to stating that any such aid must be submitted for Commission approval, pursuant to Article 93 of the Treaty, which does not in any way imply that the Commission would be in favour of aid for vehicle replacement.