Recital 14, Decision_act (EU) 1997/606

In forcesince 26 Jun 1997
(2)

Article 90 provides for an exception to the application of the Treaty rules in the case on undertakings 'entrusted with the operation of services of general economic interest` in so far as the application of those rules would obstruct the performance, in law or in fact, of the particular tasks assigned to them.

The Belgian authorities have not cited this saving provision. In any event, VTM would not appear to be entrusted with the operation of a service of general economic interest. Article 41 of the Codex merely authorizes VTM to arrange television broadcasts aimed at the Flemish community. The provisions of the Codex requiring VTM to ensure balance in its programming, to contribute to the general development of the Flemish public, to maintain objectivity in its journalism and not to broadcast programmes contrary to public morals or security do not stand as evidence that VTM has been assigned a task of general economic interest by the Flemish authorities. These are very general requirements in respect of VTM's programme content; in no way do they point to the conclusion that the Flemish community has given VTM the task of carrying out one of its cultural policies. A distinction has to be made between, on the one hand, the conditions of authorization which a private television corporation must satisfy on grounds of public interest, that is to say conditions of the kind imposed on VTM, and on the other hand the State's assignment to a private firm of a task in the public interest. The Commission notes that the Codex expressly gives the responsibility of acting as a 'public television corporation` to BRTN, whose capital is held by the Flemish community. As well as having to perform this role as a 'public television corporation`, BRTN is subject to specific public service obligations, requiring it for example to carry Flemish Government broadcasts and party-political broadcasts, and to provide air time for associations representing various schools of thought. None of these requirements applies to VTM. A recent amendment to the Codex further specifies the public service obligations imposed on BRTN, which is to be renamed VRT. VRT is here required to conclude a management contract with the Flemish authorities which will spell out VRT's public service mission in more detail (22).

Lastly, even if it were to be accepted that VTM has a public service function, the means by which it is to be performed, namely the exclusive rights which are the subject of this Decision, affect trade to an extent which is disproportionate and contrary to the interests of the Community, and such as to deprive Article 52 of any effect despite the fact that effective competition in television advertising in Flanders would facilitated if other television broadcasters were permitted to establish themselves there. The fact that they would then be operating close to their audience and to their advertisers would make their work easier and less burdensome,