Recital 13, Decision_act (EU) 1997/606

In forcesince 26 Jun 1997

In the course of the proceedings in Case C-211/91 Commission v. Belgium, cited above, the Belgian authorities put forward the argument that part of VTM's advertising revenue was transferred to the press as compensation for the loss of income due to the introduction of commercial advertising on radio and television, so that the intention was to maintain pluralism in the Flemish press. Thus the Flemish Government initially invoked arguments of cultural policy to justify the granting of a monopoly in television advertising to VTM. But in the light of the present structure of VTM, and of developments in the media and in the Flemish press, where there have been several mergers and alliances, the Flemish Government now takes the view (in its letter of 11 February 1997 in reply to the Commission's letter of 10 January 1997) that this measure is no longer likely to secure an objective in the public interest. The Flemish Government doubts, therefore, whether the measure qualifies for the saving clause in Article 90 (2).

VTM, however, is still arguing along these lines. According to VTM, the transfer of advertising revenue to the publishers of Flemish newspapers is an essential component in the function given to it in the public interest, and is directly related to its monopoly right. Another aspect of this function is the way in which it complements the public broadcaster, BRTN, and the local television stations, especially by providing a general news and information service on an independent basis and by broadcasting educational and entertainment programmes.

The Commission accepts that a cultural policy and the preservation of pluralism, which is an aspect of the freedom of expression, may constitute imperative requirements in the public interest such as to justify the restriction of the freedom of establishment. But the means to those ends must not limit the freedoms established by the Treaty any more than is necessary. The objectives in the present case must not be pursued by methods which eliminate any competition which the domestic broadcaster might otherwise have to face from media organizations wishing to establish themselves in Belgium in order to distribute their own advertisements via cable distribution networks: that would deprive Article 52 of any effect whatsoever.

The Commission takes the view that in this case there is no necessary relationship between the purported cultural policy objective of preserving pluralism in the Flemish press and the grant in Flanders of a private commercial television monopoly to VTM. First, the Codex does not guarantee every Flemish newspaper publisher, without distinction, the right to become a shareholder in VTM or to receive a return from its profits. If a newspaper publisher did not take part in the setting-up of VTM, which is the case for example of those that entered the Flemish press market after 1987, the law does not confer it any entitlement to share in the profits generated by VTM. The exclusive right conferred on VTM merely favours one group of publishers at the expense of others. The publishers enjoying this privilege are given a secure monopoly income guaranteed by law, which will enable them to compete more effectively with any competitors or new entrants to the Flemish press market, including those from other Member States. In addition, there is no guarantee that VTM's advertising revenue, which is divided among the shareholders in proportion to their holdings in the capital, will be used by them to help their newspapers to overcome possible financial difficulties. Such revenue might equally well be used for activities having no cultural purpose whatsoever, and quite unconnected with support for the Flemish press. Thus, VTM's monopoly runs counter to the stated objective of ensuring pluralism in the Flemish press.

Secondly, the conditions laid down in the Codex regarding the structure of the only private television corporation in Flanders to have received the authorization of the Flemish executive, that is to say the provisions reserving 51 % of VTM's capital for Flemish press publishers, are ill-suited to the attainment of the stated cultural aim, since it is not impossible that VTM's capital, and more particularly the reserved 51 % portion, might come to be concentrated in the hands of a single shareholder, at the expense of any preservation of pluralism in the media. Indeed, whereas VTM had originally consisted of nine shareholders, only five are left today (21).

Turning to the question of the viability of broadcasting stations, there is no reason to suppose that a private television station cannot survive in the Flemish community without a monopoly on television advertising. Indeed, the fact that VTM in 1995 launched a second television channel carrying advertising shows that it believes that more than one private channel can be profitable in Flanders.

To sum up, the Commission does not believe that VTM's monopolization of advertising revenue is justified on imperative grounds in the public interest. To ensure the pluralism which it hopes to maintain, the Flemish Government could have recourse to appropriate measure which do not impede economic integration to so great an extent.