Recital 10, Decision_act (EU) 1997/606

In forcesince 26 Jun 1997

Claiming that the monopoly on television advertising in Flanders favours the private broadcaster VTM and disadvantages foreign television broadcasters, the company VT4 Ltd ('VT4`) has lodged a complaint with the Commission. VT4, whose sole shareholder is the Luxembourg company Scandinavian Broadcasting System SA (SBS), is a company established in London under English law, whose main activity is to broadcast television programmes. On 13 September 1994, VT4 obtained a licence from the United Kingdom authorities to broadcast programmes via satellite (a 'non-domestic satellite broadcasting licence`). Since 1 February 1995, VT4 has been broadcasting television programmes under that licence.

VT4's programmes are targeted at the Flemish public. They are either produced or sub-titled in Dutch.

The television signal is transmitted towards the satellite from UK territory. By letter of 17 October 1995, the UK authorities informed the Commission that VT4 falls under UK jurisdiction within the meaning of Article 2 (1) of Directive 89/552/EEC.

By letter of 13 July 1995, the Commission asked the Belgian Government to provide details concerning the compatibility of the Flemish legislation on the television-advertising monopoly with the Community rules on freedom to provide services. The Belgian Government's reply of 14 September 1995 states that the wording of the legislation in question does not prohibit television channels established in other Member States from broadcasting advertising targeted at the Flemish public and that, consequently, it is consistent with Article 59 of the Treaty.

However, the Flemish authorities do not consider VT4 to be a broadcaster approved by another Member State, on the ground that it is a Flemish broadcaster established in the UK in order to circumvent the legislation of the Flemish community. Moreover the Flemish authorities argue that VT4 falls outside the scope of Article 10 (1), point 2, of the Cable Directive, which requires cable operators to distribute the programmes of the authorized non-public television company covering the Flemish community as a whole: this is so because VTM is the only authorized private broadcaster. For these reasons, VT4 was, by Ministerial Order, refused access to the Flemish cable network (17). This Order was suspended by the Belgian Raad van State/Conseil d'État, which then referred the matter to the Court of Justice for a preliminary ruling with a view to determining which broadcasters fall within a Member State's jurisdiction within the meaning of Directive 89/552/EEC. By judgment of 5 June 1997 (18), the Court ruled that, where a television broadcaster is established in more than one Member State, it falls within the jurisdiction of the Member State on whose territory its centre of activities is located. The Court also considered that the mere fact that all of its programmes are targeted at a Flemish public does not mean that VT4 cannot be regarded as being established in the United Kingdom.