, Decision_act (EU) 1996/671

In forcesince 13 Nov 1996

Given that the determining criterion for application of this Article is the severity of the infringement committed, it is first necessary to carry out both an objective and a subjective analysis of the nature of the offences.

From an objective point of view, it appears that the provisions breached are essential elements of Community legislation in the field of safeguards.

Moreover, the facts established made it impossible for the Commission to carry out the task assigned to it in Article 2 (e) of the Treaty, namely to 'make certain, by appropriate supervision, that nuclear materials are not diverted to purposes other than those for which they are intended`.

However, while being aware that the Euratom Treaty obligations are designed to ensure that all nuclear materials, including source materials, are properly accounted for, recorded and reported, the amount and type of nuclear material involved are taken into consideration. In this case the material concerned had a low strategic value.

From a subjective point of view, it appears that Jenson Tungsten Ltd has failed to keep appropriate records and reports for the nuclear material kept on site and that a materials accounting system did not exist for a long time despite requests and various reminders. This would normally lead to the imposition of a sanction according to Article 83 (1) (c).

Taking into consideration that Jenson Tungsten Ltd is not carrying out any activity involving nuclear material and that it is holding its predecessor's depleted uranium swarf awaiting disposal, Jenson Tungsten Ltd should establish and keep records of the depleted uranium swarf remaining on site and affix appropriate labels to each of the drums containing the material. Those labels must indicate, in addition to the unique identification number, the contents and estimated weight of the contents. Furthermore Jenson Tungsten Ltd should declare any future movements of nuclear material, in particular the shipment of the remaining depleted uranium swarf for disposal according to the Commission regulations in force. A system of source documentation for future movements must be established.

In appreciating both the objective and the subjective factors set out above, the infringements committed by Jenson Tungsten Ltd are such that a sanction is warranted.