, Decision_act (EU) 1994/698

In forcesince 6 Jul 1994

Those comfort letters have enabled TAP to obtain credit facilities from some Portuguese and foreign credit institutions. The comfort letters, by assuring the lenders that the Government is behind the airline, improve TAP's borrowing position and may be considered as guarantees. This character is undisputed by the Portuguese Government.

C. Tax exemption

TAP enjoys a tax exemption. This fiscal privilege was established before the accession of Portugal to the Community. The tax exemption is an individual aid because it reduces the burdens which an undertaking should normally bear. Because of the tax exemption the undertaking benefits from a competitive advantage over its competitors which do not benefit from similar privileges. The Portuguese Government informed the Commission that it will abolish the tax exemption at the end of the restructuring period only. The company estimates the total amount of the exemption, for the period 1994 to 1997, at about Esc 8 billion. Thus the tax exemption can now be considered to be another aid measure in the framework of the restructuring plan.

TAP is an airline which operates several European routes on which, as a consequence of the liberalization of the common air transport market, competition is intense. Because of the projected capital increase and the credit guarantees, TAP receives a direct competitive advantage over its competitors who do not enjoy such facilities; thus the aid distorts competition within the common market. Moreover, the aid affects trade in the EEA because it is granted to a company which operates in the air tranpsort sector which involves by its nature trans-border operations.

Accordingly, the Commission believes that the notified capital increase and credit guarantees (including the non-notified guarantees in the form of comfort letters) as well as the tax exemption are aid within the scope of Article 92 (1) of the Treaty and Article 61 (1) of the Agreement. The latter guarantees should have been notified to the Commission pursuant to Article 93 (3) of the Treaty.

The aid to TAP cannot be considered compatible with the common market pursuant to Article 92 (2) of the Treaty and Article 61 (2) of the Agreement, since the aid does not correspond to any of the hypotheses under those provisions.