, Decision_act (EU) 1994/698

In forcesince 6 Jul 1994
1.

that the plan is adequate to enable TAP to eliminate its problems and become, within the restructuring period, an efficient air carrier. The productivity and efficiency targets of the plan, which some of TAP's competitors have already achieved, appeared to be insufficient to restore viability;

2.

that the recapitalization as set out in the plan is sufficient to bring the airline's financial ratios into more prudent limits;

3.

that some changes (a more gradual reduction of personnel and the payment of the capital injection in four tranches instead of a one-off capital increase) made to the scenario submitted by the consultants do not jeopardize the objectives of the plan;

4.

that the possible under-compensation of the deficit incurred by fulfilling the public service obligation requirements on the routes to the Atlantic islands of Azores and Madeira does not lead to substantial losses which might impair the success of the plan;

5.

that the aid does not affect trading conditions to an extent contrary to the common interest.

VI The interested third parties that have commented on the case have mainly expressed doubts on the adequacy of the restructuring measures in the plan and concerns that the aid may be used by TAP for anticompetitive purposes. In particular, with the aid TAP may dump fares and capacity on European routes to the detriment of its competitors. Moreover, the Portuguese authorities shall encourage competition by opening up handling activities to third parties at Portuguese airports.

The comments submitted by the Portuguese authorities, which provided useful information on the development of the plan, as well as the replies to the different points raised in the opening of the procedure, may be summarized as follows:

1.

As regards the productivity targets, the value of 242 ATK/employee ATK-employee to be achieved by the last year of the plan represents a growth of nearly 50 % over the four years of the plan. However, if one excludes from the total number of personnel those employees (34 % of the total workforce) who in 1997 will be working exclusively for third parties in the maintenance and handling areas, this figure would reach 366 000.