, Decision_act (EU) 1994/698

In forcesince 6 Jul 1994

The Court of Justice has specified that the behaviour of a private investor, with which the intervention of the public investor has to be compared, has to be at least that of a private holding or of a private group which follows a structural, global or sectoral policy and which is guided by profitability perspectives in the longer term (6).

The Portuguese authorities have duly notified to the Commission, pursuant to Article 93 of the Treaty, the projected capital increase as aid in favour of TAP. However, in the notification they maintain that 'a private investor, in the conditions of a market economy and having a long-range outlook, could be willing to make an investment identical to that which the State proposes to make, given that there are consistent perspectives of profitability after the period of implementation of the restructuring programme'. The Commission does not share the Portuguese Government's opinion. In the present case the Commission considers that the rational private investor, taking into due account the ailing financial structure of the Portuguese airline, would not have agreed to invest money in TAP. It must be recalled that, according to the plan, the operating results will become positive in 1996 and the company will attain its first positive net result in 1997 only. This profitability outlook, together with the huge amount of debts and accumulated losses burdening the airline's financial accounts, as described above (Chapter III), would dissuade a private investor from investing any money in TAP because it is impossible to expect a normal return on the investment within a reasonable period of time. Therefore the Commission considers that the notified capital increase is an aid.

B. Guarantees