Mr Vygen's note, referred to in recital 33, shows that the companies or persons mentioned therein regularly participated in the meetings of the Poutrelles Committee. In the course of the proceedings the undertakings and associations concerned provided the following more specific information:
Peine-Salzgitter confirmed that it had attended all the meetings listed above;
The Walzstahl-Vereinigung informed the Commission that it had participated in all the meetings listed above apart from the one on 3 May 1988;
British Steel confirmed that it had attended all the meetings listed above apart from those on 10 January and 6 June 1989. The evidence (a list of participants and a British Steel memo on the results of that meeting) shows, however, that British Steel also attended the meeting on 10 January 1989;
Arbed informed the Commission that its subsidiary TradeArbed had in principle attended all the meetings listed above;
Ensidesa confirmed that it had attended, through its subsidiary Infisa GmbH (a trading company incorporated in Germany), all the meetings listed above apart from those on 21 September and 7 November 1989;
Thyssen confirmed that it had attended all the meetings listed above in the period from 25 November 1987, apart from the meeting on 7 November 1989;
Unimétal informed the Commission that it had been represented at all the meetings listed above until the end of 1989. The person who had represented Unimétal at these meetings moved to Aciers d'Usinor et Sacilor (Valor) (16) at the beginning of 1990. Valor initially confirmed that these meetings were attended by Valor from the beginning of 1990. However, the evidence shows that the person concerned continued to act for Unimétal (see for example an undated note from Unimétal to the secretariat of the Poutrelles Committee which was written on or before 18 May 1990 and notes that Unimétal had not been able to attend the last meeting of the Committee, clearly implying that Unimétal normally still attended these meetings). This was confirmed by Unimétal at the oral hearing;
Saarstahl confirmed that it had attended the meetings on 19 May 1987, 3 May, 18 October, 15 November and 13 December 1988, all the meetings held in 1989 and the meetings on 14 February, 16 May, 11 September and 4 December 1990. The evidence (a note on the meeting prepared by Peine-Salzgitter) shows that it had also been present at the meeting on 25 November 1987;
Cockerill Sambre and Steelinter told the Commission that they had attended the meetings on 19 July, 18 October and 15 November 1988, 10 January, 7 February and 3 August 1989 and probably also the meeting on 6 June 1989. The evidence shows that Cockerill Sambre had also been present on 11 July 1989 (see the minutes of the meeting);
Ferdofin confirmed that it had attended some of the meetings although it could not specify the dates. The evidence shows, however, that Ferdofin attended these meetings on a regular basis at least since 1987. This is confirmed by the note on the Poutrelles Committee drawn up by the Walzstahl-Vereinigung (see recital 33). With reference to some of the meetings listed above, Ferdofin claimed, in its reply to the Statement of Objections, that the Commission had not proved Ferdofin's participation. However, the minutes of the meeting on 19 April 1989, the list of participants of the meeting on 14 February 1990 and correspondence concerning the meeting on 7 February 1989 (draft letter from Ferdofin to Mr Meyer and Mr Meyer's reply dated 29 March 1989) show that Ferdofin had attended these meetings;
Aristrain confirmed that it attended all the meetings in 1989 and 1990 apart from those on 21 September and 12 December 1989, 21 March, 10 July and 4 December 1990. However, the reference to 'a Spanish mill' in the minutes of the meeting on 21 September 1989 (where Ensidesa was not represented) shows that Aristrain attended this meeting. It may be inferred from the note of the Walzstahl-Vereinigung on the Poutrelles Committee together with the note of Peine-Salzgitter on the meeting on 25 November 1987 that Aristrain attended these meetings regularly at least from 1987 onwards.
1.3. Monitoring
1.1.3. Monitoring of orders until mid 1990