Recital 41, Decision_act (EU) 1994/19

In forcesince 21 Dec 1993

SC wrote to the Commission on 25 June 1993 in response to the Sealink letter. SC said that Sealink had not offered any terms which could be described as precise and that it had not been demonstrated that there was substantial available capacity at existing facilities (on the west side of the port). There was no flexibility for SC to change its timetable, and Sealink admitted that disruption might occur due to congestion, adverse weather conditions etc. The port charges were very high in comparison with, for example, Dun Laoghaire, and this was to Sealink's own benefit, as charges paid by it as a ferry company were received by it as port operator.

SC said that there was more than adequate capacity on the east side of the harbour, and therefore there was no need to concentrate all ferry operators at existing western berths with the resultant problems of slot allocation and congestion. Sealink had indicated that the redevelopment, which was originally scheduled to be completed by the spring of 1994 and was now apparently scheduled for completion in 1995, was far from certain, being dependent on grant aid. Sea Container had indicated its willingness to pay for the temporary facilities necessary and to move at 14 days' notice when Sealink required. SC maintains that Sealink's behaviour is not that which would have been expected of an independent port operator and is attributable to its wish to protect its ferry services from competition. An independent port operator would have actively sought new business for the port and would have sought constructively to find solutions to any technical obstacles which might have arisen.