In the said letter of 28 December 1992, the reason given for refusing Viva Air permission to operate into Paris (CDG) was that Iberia and Viva Air were part of the same group and that their respective services would therefore not be independent of each other. What general criteria do the French authorities use to decide whether two companies are in fact members of the same group or a single company for the purposes of applying the rules governing the allocation of traffic to Orly and CDG? In this connection, how is the interdependence between companies determined?
As the Commission did not receive a reply by the deadline given, the French authorities were sent a reminder on 5 March 1993, allowing five days for the authorities to reply. In a letter dated 11 March 1993 and logged in at the Commission on 17 March, the French authorities sent the Commission the information it had requested.
IV The replies of the French authorities to the six questions the Commission put in its letter of 4 February 1993 may be summarized as follows:
Questions one and two: the provisions of Article 3 of Regulation (EEC) No 2408/92 do not prevent application of the procedure established by the Decree of 12 September 1980. Nevertheless, it is intended to amend the Decree so as to reduce to one month the period required for notification - it having already been reduced to two months.
Question 3: since the entry into force of Council Regulation (EEC) No 2407/92 (3), all French carriers, including the flag carrier, have to meet the same requirements to obtain an operating licence, a process which involves an opinion from the Conseil supérieur de l'Aviation Marchande (CSAM) and the lodging of a programme one month prior to start-up.
Question 4: the Ministerial decisions allocating traffic to the various airports in the Paris system are not issued as formal documents but are based on the principles formulated by the French Government when setting out its air transport policy. These principles were analysed in detail when Paris (CDG) airport was built and again more recently. A Ministerial decision collating all the rules on allocating traffic to the Paris airport system should be issued shortly.
Question 5: the decision to apply the principle of not allowing the same airline to serve both Paris (Orly) and Paris (CDG) to medium-haul international flights only was taken because of the type of market involved.