, Decision_act (EU) 1993/347

In forcesince 28 May 1993

On the question of allocating traffic to airports, the policy has been gradually to transfer to Paris (CDG) all airlines formerly operating through Orly. For instance, in October 1980, once the CDG 2 terminal came into operation, the French authorities decided to transfer foreign (particularly Community) airlines from Orly-West to terminal CDG 1. It therefore has to be said that the refusal of the authorities to allow Viva Air to operate the Madrid-Paris (CDG) service runs counter to their policy on these airports so far.

The grounds given for the refusal were that the French Government operated a rule by which it did not allow airlines to run services on the same medium-haul international route from both Paris (Orly) and Paris (CDG). One wonders why this rule applies only to medium-haul international traffic and not also to domestic and to international long-haul services. The French authorities say that this differentiation is due to the type of market involved.

Turning first to long-haul services, the Commission would nevertheless note that only the French flag carrier operates an international long-haul service with departures from both Orly and CDG (Paris-New York) at frequencies comparable with those of many intra-Community airlines.

Taking the medium-haul services next, the Commission cannot accept at face value the explanations provided by the French authorities, namely that, as opposed to the situation in domestic French flights, intra-Community international flights operated by a single company may not serve both Orly and CDG because of the low level of competition with surface transport, the low level of traffic flows and the existence of several competing companies. In the first place, such a general and complete separation of national and international intra-Community flights is contrary to the very principle of a single Community market. Secondly, on several domestic French routes - and not the shortest either - there is little competition from surface transport whereas there is such competition on major intra-Community international routes departing from Paris. Thirdly, the difference in the size of traffic flows is not so great as to justify different treatment and it should be pointed out that the Paris-London route is the busiest of all intra-Community routes. Lastly, domestic French flights are now also open to competition since the Community rules establishing a single internal market in civil aviation came into force on 1 January 1993.